Roblox 2017 Halloween Limiteds: All 7 Items and Values

Roblox put seven classic Limiteds on the catalog in the run-up to Halloween 2017, and they split into two groups that behave very differently today. A Limited is an avatar item sold in a fixed number of copies that owners can resell to each other, and a classic Limited is one Roblox made itself, while a UGC Limited comes from a community creator. Three of the seven sold at a high price on a countdown timer and only became tradeable years afterwards, led by King of the Dark Crop at a 153,557 RAP across 100 copies. The other four sold out against a stock cap, and the largest of them, Dangerous Eye Patch, minted 32,212 copies and sits at a 587 RAP. RAP means recent average price, Roblox's smoothed average of an item's whole sale history.

Quick answer: Seven classic Limiteds carry a late September or October 2017 catalog date, 51,515 copies between them. King of the Dark Crop leads at a 153,557 RAP, then Immortal Sword: Vlad's Lament at 58,746 and Mischief Bowler at 8,965, all three of them timer sales that Roblox converted to Limited in 2022. The four cheapest items in the batch are the ones that sold out at a stock cap in 2017.

What were Roblox's 2017 Halloween Limiteds? Seven items holding 51,515 copies

Below is every classic Limited Roblox put on the catalog between September 30 and the end of October 2017, ordered by what traders agree each one is worth. Lowest ask means the cheapest copy a reseller has listed right now. The consensus order and the RAP order match on this batch, which makes it easy to read.

Item	Catalog date	Original price	Copies	RAP	Lowest ask
King of the Dark Crop	October 20	31,000 R$	100	153,557	588,888
Immortal Sword: Vlad's Lament	September 30	10,000 R$	1,284	58,746	99,999
Mischief Bowler	October 19	1,000 R$	913	8,965	7,100
Halloween Formal Top Hat	October 19	750 R$	2,000	7,017	6,500
Halloween Plungerpack	October 6	500 R$	5,004	1,800	3,099
Noob Assist: Undead Unrest	October 19	75 R$	10,002	1,057	1,075
Dangerous Eye Patch	October 19	250 R$	32,212	587	500

Four of the seven landed on October 19, Roblox's big Halloween catalog drop that year. The dates in that column are the asset creation dates in Roblox's own item records, which is when the item appeared on the catalog and can run ahead of the sale window. Roblox Wiki pages put King of the Dark Crop's actual sale on October 31, eleven days after the asset went up, so read that October 20 as a catalog stamp.

You can see the whole classic hat side of the market, 2017 included, on the classic hats collection, and every Limited with a RAP above 100,000 Robux on the most expensive Limiteds collection.

Why do some 2017 Halloween items have serial numbers and others don't?

Roblox ran two different sale formats that month, and the format decided everything about how each item aged.

Four items sold as Limited U, which is short for Limited Unique. Roblox sets a stock number, the copies sell at a fixed price until they run out, and every copy carries a serial number showing which one in the run it is. Halloween Plungerpack (5,004 copies), Halloween Formal Top Hat (2,000), Noob Assist: Undead Unrest (10,002) and Dangerous Eye Patch (32,212) all work this way. Those four hold 49,218 of the batch's 51,515 copies. Roblox's item records still flag all four as Limited Unique today.

The other three sold as ordinary catalog items on a countdown timer with no stock cap and no serials. Supply was whatever people bought before the clock ran out. Mischief Bowler took 913 buyers, Immortal Sword: Vlad's Lament took 1,284, and King of the Dark Crop took 100. When the timer ended the items went offsale, which means Roblox stops selling them, and for years they sat in inventories as untradeable items. Roblox converted all three into Limiteds in 2022, which switched on resale and trading for copies that had been frozen since 2017.

For the mechanics in full, we cover the badge difference in Limited vs Limited U on Roblox, the serials in Roblox Limited serial numbers, and conversions like these in offsale Roblox items going Limited.

The market result is blunt. The 2,297 copies from timer sales hold the top three RAPs in the batch; the 49,218 copies from stock caps hold the bottom four. A stock cap tells you exactly how many will exist, and when that number is 32,212 the item has nowhere to go.

King of the Dark Crop: a 31,000 Robux crown that waited five years to trade

This is the gem of the 2017 class, and a gem in our vocabulary is a scarce, high-value Limited that traders treat as a store of value. It is a black crown with a small pumpkin on the tip and a pair of Sinister P faces on the sides, and Roblox sold it for 31,000 Robux on a one-day timer at the very end of the month. Our catalog counts 100 copies while the Roblox Wiki records 96 purchases in that window, so take the exact mint with a pinch of salt. Either way, barely anyone bought it.

At 31,000 Robux in 2017 that was a huge ask for a hat, and little about it looked like a safe purchase. It had no series behind it, no event tie-in, and no resale market at all, because the item carried no Limited status and could not be sold on. It stayed that way for nearly five years. Roblox Wiki records date the flip to Limited status to September 1, 2022, and Roblox's own item record for the asset was last touched the following day, so 100 copies walked into a market that had spent half a decade without them.

RAP currently reads 153,557 while the cheapest listed copy asks 588,888. That gap is the signature of a thin market. With 100 copies in existence and almost no sales to feed into the average, RAP lags a long way behind what holders actually want, and trader consensus on this crown sits well above the RAP figure. It currently shows 3,370 favourites in our data, which for a 100-copy item is a lot of people watching. More crowns, this one included, rank live on the crowns collection.

Immortal Sword: Vlad's Lament, the 10,000 Robux sword on a 96-hour clock

Roblox opened the horror run on September 30, 2017 with a vampire-themed back accessory priced at 10,000 Robux on a four-day timer. It belongs to the Immortal Sword line, a family of back-slung blades that Roblox has sold at premium prices for years, and its name nods to Vlad the Impaler, the figure behind Roblox's long-running Vlad hat series.

1,284 copies exist. RAP is 58,746 and the cheapest listing asks 99,999. Like the crown, it went Limited later, on May 29, 2022, so its whole resale history is only a few years long despite the 2017 catalog date. The series connection gives it a floor the one-off items in this batch don't have: collectors chasing the full Immortal Sword set need this piece, and only 1,284 exist. The full line sits on the Immortal Sword collection, and we told its story in the Immortal Sword series history.

Mischief Bowler: the cheapest way into the 2017 timer group

Mischief Bowler cost 1,000 Robux on October 19 and took 913 buyers before it went offsale, which leaves it scarcer than everything in the batch except the crown. Roblox turned it Limited in September 2022. RAP sits at 8,965 and the lowest ask is 7,100, so the cheapest copy is listed under the average, one of the few below-RAP entries here. At four figures this is the accessible end of the 2017 timer items. Bowlers have a history of their own, which we walk through in the bowler series history.

Did Roblox's 2017 Halloween event give out any Limiteds? No, the prizes were free items

Roblox ran Hallow's Eve 2017 from October 18 to October 31, sponsored by Nerf, built around an event game called Hallow's Eve 2017: A Tale of Lost Souls plus quests in Azure Mines and Blox Hunt, according to the Roblox Wiki's page on the event. Players who finished the objectives earned items like the Skeletal Crown, the Ghostly Tricorn Hat and a set of Nerf Zombie Strike accessories, and a Hallows' Eve Zombie Mask went to anyone who collected the lot.

None of those prizes were Limiteds. They were free items with unlimited supply, so they have no copy count, no RAP and no resale market, and they still sit in the inventories of everyone who played. Our catalog carries the Ghostly Tricorn Hat at a 0 Robux price with no Limited status, which lines up.

Hallow's Eve was the second half of the month's free-prize run. Nightmare Before Bloxtober ran October 3 to 16 under a Thor: Ragnarok sponsorship and handed out Loki's Helm, Thor's Helmet, Hulk's Helmet and three Guise masks, with Korg's Mask for finishing the set. Our catalog carries those at 0 Robux with no Limited status as well. October 2017 ran four straight weeks of free event items on one track and paid Limiteds on another, and all the lasting Robux value landed in the paid ones.

That split matters when you read older Halloween years. In 2016 the famous Dominus Praefectus came out of a 31,000 Robux gift box tied to the season, as our write-up on Roblox's 2016 Halloween Limiteds covers. A year later the free prizes and the paid Limiteds ran on separate tracks.

What does the 2017 batch tell a collector today? Supply format beats theme

The lesson from this one month is that how an item sold matters more than what it looked like. Every item in the table is Halloween-themed, their RAPs span 587 to 153,557, and the split tracks almost exactly with sale format.

Return multiples against the original price tell a slightly different story:

• Noob Assist: Undead Unrest cost 75 Robux and carries a 1,057 RAP, about 14 times its price. Best multiple in the batch.
• Halloween Formal Top Hat cost 750 and reads 7,017, about 9 times.
• King of the Dark Crop cost 31,000 and reads 153,557, about 5 times.
• Dangerous Eye Patch cost 250 and reads 587, about 2.3 times. Worst multiple in the batch.

Cheap items with moderate supply did proportionally better than the expensive ones, a pattern you see across the classic market. The catch is that a 14x on 75 Robux is 982 Robux of gain, while a 5x on 31,000 is over 120,000.

For anyone buying one of these now, run the fee math first. A classic Limited resale carries a 30% marketplace fee, so a seller keeps 70% of the sale price, and that means you need roughly 1.43 times your purchase price just to break even. Buy a Halloween Formal Top Hat at its 6,500 lowest ask and you need to sell near 9,300 before you have made a single Robux. Our marketplace fees guide runs through the arithmetic in detail. Buying a classic Limited from a reseller also starts a 7-day holding period, a stretch where the copy sits in your inventory and cannot be sold on, so plan on the item being stuck for a week.

October is when Halloween classics get the most attention, and prices in the category often move with it. We tested how reliable that pattern is in do Roblox Halloween Limiteds go up in October, and the rarest items across every Halloween year are collected in Roblox's rarest Halloween Limiteds. To watch any of these seven for a below-average listing, the items leaderboard ranks the whole catalog live and the Deals feed flags Limiteds listed under RAP as it happens, once you are signed in.

None of this is financial advice. Limiteds are virtual items, prices on thin markets swing hard, and a RAP figure averages past sales, so the next one can land well away from it.

Figures in this article come from RBX Invest catalog data as of October 2026, item status and total quantities from Roblox's own asset details records, fee and holding-period rules from Roblox's marketplace documentation, and release dates, sale windows and event details from the Roblox Wiki on Fandom.

FAQ

What were Roblox's 2017 Halloween Limiteds?

Seven classic Limiteds carry a September 30 to October 2017 catalog date: King of the Dark Crop, Immortal Sword: Vlad's Lament, Mischief Bowler, Halloween Formal Top Hat, Halloween Plungerpack, Noob Assist: Undead Unrest and Dangerous Eye Patch. Together they hold 51,515 copies, and none are still on sale from Roblox.

Which 2017 Halloween Limited is worth the most?

King of the Dark Crop, by a wide margin. It carries a 153,557 RAP across just 100 copies, and the cheapest copy listed by a reseller asks 588,888 Robux. Second place is Immortal Sword: Vlad's Lament at a 58,746 RAP across 1,284 copies.

Why do some 2017 Halloween items have serial numbers and others don't?

Because Roblox sold them in two formats. Halloween Plungerpack, Halloween Formal Top Hat, Noob Assist: Undead Unrest and Dangerous Eye Patch sold as Limited U, meaning a fixed stock where every copy gets a serial number. King of the Dark Crop, Mischief Bowler and Immortal Sword: Vlad's Lament sold as ordinary timed catalog items with no serials, and Roblox only converted them into tradeable Limiteds in 2022.

Can you still buy a King of the Dark Crop?

Only from another player. Roblox's copies sold out during the original sale and the item has been offsale ever since, so the resale market is the only route. The cheapest listing currently asks 588,888 Robux, and with 100 copies in existence there are rarely many listed at once.

Was the Halloween Plungerpack tradeable when it came out?

Yes. It sold as a Limited U back accessory in October 2017 with a 5,004-copy stock, so copies carried serial numbers and had a resale market from the start, with no later conversion needed. It reads a 1,800 RAP today with a 3,099 lowest ask, which puts the cheapest listing above the average.

Did Roblox's 2017 Hallow's Eve event hand out any Limiteds?

No. The Nerf-sponsored event that ran October 18 to 31, 2017 gave out free items with unlimited supply, including the Skeletal Crown, the Ghostly Tricorn Hat and several Nerf Zombie Strike accessories. Those have no copy count and no resale value. The paid Limiteds that month were separate catalog drops.

How many copies of the 2017 Halloween Limiteds exist?

51,515 across all seven items. Four stock-capped Limited U items account for 49,218 of those, and 32,212 of them are Dangerous Eye Patch alone. The three timer items hold only 2,297 copies between them, which is why they sit at the top of the price table.

Which 2017 Halloween Limited gained the most relative to its original price?

Noob Assist: Undead Unrest. It cost 75 Robux in 2017 and carries a 1,057 RAP today, roughly 14 times its price and the best multiple in the batch. In absolute Robux the biggest gain is King of the Dark Crop, from 31,000 to a 153,557 RAP.